ToolScore

A .com Is All You Need: The 10-Year Math Against .io, .ai, .dev and .app

$118 vs $494 vs $827 per decade the number that matters here

By Stan K.

A flat-price registrar sells .com at $11.81 — the same verified number for registration, renewal and transfer — which is $118.10 over ten years. The same decade costs $494.32 on .io (Porkbun, $51.80 renewals) or $827 on .ai (2-year minimum, $165.40 upfront). .dev and .app are cheap but force HTTPS from day one via the HSTS preload list. When the specialty TLD is still worth it — and when it is a promo-year trap.

The default answer for an indie builder’s domain is still .com, and the reason is arithmetic, not nostalgia. Every alternative TLD is a real product with real advantages — shorter names, category signaling, availability — but the price gap over a project’s lifetime is enormous, verified, and almost never shown as a single number. So here is the single number, then the honest exceptions.

The baseline: one flat, verified price

Porkbun’s .com, returned verbatim by the official pricing API: registration $11.81, renewal $11.81, transfer $11.81. One number for all three events, with WHOIS privacy free for life and no nameserver lock. A standing −$1 coupon makes year one $10.81, but the honest planning figure is the flat one — because the flat one is what years two through ten cost. Ten years: $118.10.

That flatness is the feature. Namecheap’s verified .com ladder runs a $12.08 first-year sale into a $19.98 renewal — plus 65% at the first renewal — and even .com pricing moves at the wholesale layer (Squarespace says publicly that “registries raised wholesale prices” while raising its .com, .net, .org and .xyz renewals). A flat-price registrar passes wholesale moves through and nothing more; a promo registrar adds a year-two cliff on top. “A .com is all you need” silently assumes the first kind of registrar. We are saying it out loud.

The 10-year table

Verified unit prices, real 10-year totals, no promo assumptions after year one:

DomainYear 1RenewalMinimum term10-year totalThe catch
.com (Porkbun)$11.81$11.81/yr1 year$118.10Moves only when registry wholesale moves
.com (Namecheap)$12.08 sale$19.98/yr1 year$191.90+65% at first renewal
.io (Porkbun)$28.12 promo$51.80/yr1 year$494.32Uncapped ccTLD pricing; long-term governance tail risk
.io (101domain)$69.99$73.49/yr1 year$731.40Same TLD, higher markup
.ai (Porkbun)$165.40 (2 yrs)$82.70/yr2 years$827.00Double-length bet on an unproven project
.ai (101domain)~$200 (2 yrs: $49.99 + $150)$143/yr2 years$1,343.99The promo year hides the renewal
Ten years of a domain name, verified totals
.ai — 101domain $1,343.99
.ai — Porkbun $827.00
.io — 101domain $731.40
.io — Porkbun $494.32
.com — Namecheap $191.90
.com — Porkbun $118.10

The .ai rows are not typos. The 2-year minimum is registrar-documented (“2-year purchase required” at 101domain), and 101domain’s ladder — $49.99 promo year, $150 second year, $143/year renewals — is the purest promo-cliff example we verified. A .ai that survives its first decade costs seven to eleven times the flat .com.

.dev and .app: cheap to buy, mandatory HTTPS from day one

Google Registry’s .dev and .app are the counterexamples on price — registration is cheap — but they carry a different bill: both sit on the HSTS preload list, so browsers refuse plain HTTP on them, ever. Google’s own pages: .dev is “included on the HSTS preload list, making HTTPS required on all connections,” and .app is billed as “the world’s first HSTS-preloaded TLD” — “browsers will only load .app sites over a secure HTTPS connection.”

If you deploy on Cloudflare Pages, GitHub Pages or anything else where certificates are automatic, this costs you nothing and is arguably a feature. Where it bites: throwaway internal tools, local development setups, and anything that ever needed to answer on plain HTTP. A certificate becomes a prerequisite for the domain to load at all — not an optimization you schedule for later.

When the specialty TLD is still worth it

We are not arguing that .com is the only rational purchase. The rational cases:

  • The name is the product. The .com is taken, the .io is free, and the brand reads better in the TLD you want. A one-time $494 decade is cheaper than a worse name. Just enter it knowing the renewal corridor — the .io creep is verified here.
  • The TLD is the category signal. An AI product on .ai is instantly legible. That legibility costs $165.40 minimum upfront — a forced 2-year bet on a project that may not survive 6 months. Sometimes the bet is right; it should at least be priced.
  • HTTPS was the plan anyway. A developer portfolio on .dev loses nothing to HSTS and gains a signal of its own.

What is never rational: buying the specialty TLD because the first invoice was small. The promo-year-to-renewal wobble is the quietest tax in this table — .io at $28.12 then $51.80 (1.8×), .ai at $49.99 then $150 (3×), .com at $12.08 then $19.98 (1.65×). Never price a domain by its first invoice; the renewal is the product.

$118.10the verified 10-year cost of a flat-price .com

Versus $494.32 (.io, Porkbun), $827.00 (.ai, Porkbun) and $1,343.99 (.ai, 101domain) over the same decade. The .com premium never arrives as one bill — it leaks as $37.62 to $122.59 per year, every year, which is precisely why it survives scrutiny so well.

The honest .com caveats

Two, so this stays a comparison and not an ad. First, the good .com names are largely taken — the entire specialty-TLD market exists because of it, and “just get the .com” sometimes means “just get a worse .com.” Second, .com wholesale is not frozen: registries have raised wholesale prices (confirmed as fact by registrars passing it through, with no verified official figure we could print), so the flat $11.81 is a property of the registrar’s pricing policy, not of physics. The right conclusion is not “.com is magic.” It is that a flat-price registrar plus .com is the cheapest stable decade in the verified table — and every dollar above $118.10 should be buying something you can name.

The full registrar table — including the vendors whose prices we could not verify, marked as such — is in the Domains hub. The expiration mechanics behind these numbers (grace, redemption, the 45-day rule) are in the traps article.

Numbers change — the math doesn't
Token prices and plan limits shift monthly; the structural arguments in this guide age slowly. For current per-tool numbers see the live rankings.