Private email: priced per inbox and alias
The easy pick by value, not by hype. Our metric is the real limits — storage, messages per day, alias counts, reply bandwidth — and what metadata stays visible no matter how strong the cipher is. Not feature lists: a provider that markets “unlimited aliases” while metering 10MB/month of forwarding belongs in a table like this one. Every number below comes from official pages checked on 2026-11-13; where a vendor doesn’t publish (Relay pricing, Tuta sending caps), the cell stays “—”.
Encrypted mail — the limits that decide the price
Two numbers do the sorting here: what a sending day costs you (Proton is the only one that publishes it — 150/day on Free) and how many identities one subscription buys (addresses + aliases). Tuta publishes no numeric sending cap at all — dynamic limits, decided server-side. Sorted by value per dollar.
| Provider | Price /mo | Mail storage | Aliases / addresses | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| | $4.99/mo monthly $2.49/mo first-year promo ($29.88), renews $47.88/yr = $3.99/mo | 15GB shared Mail + Drive | 10 addresses | 86/100 |
| | €3/mo annual €36/yr · €3.60 monthly | 20GB | 15 extra addresses + unlimited custom-domain addresses | 82/100 |
| | $0 500MB → 1GB Mail via onboarding checklist | 1GB Mail (+5GB Drive via checklist) | 1 address + 10 hide-my-email aliases | 80/100 |
| | $6.99/mo annual $83.88/yr · monthly — (not plainly published) | 30GB | Unlimited aliases (incl. burner) | 73/100 |
| | €3/mo annual €4 monthly | 20GB Mail + 10GB Drive (doubled 2026-07-15) | 25 @mailbox.org + 50 custom + 25 disposable (90 days) | 74/100 |
| | $4.99/mo annual $59.88/yr · $6.99 monthly | 20GB | Unlimited aliases (incl. burner) | 71/100 |
| | €1/mo annual billing only | 2GB Mail (no Drive) | 3 aliases | 66/100 |
| | €8/mo annual €96/yr · €9.60 monthly | 500GB | 30 extra addresses | 68/100 |
| | €9/mo annual €12 monthly | 50GB Mail + 100GB Drive (doubled 2026-07-15) | 25 @mailbox.org + 250 custom + 50 disposable | 61/100 |
| CounterMail | $49/12mo ~$4.08/mo · $79/24mo ($3.29/mo) — prepaid | 4GB encrypted | — | 52/100 |
Click a provider for the full picture — sending caps, custom domains, IMAP details and the score breakdown on its review page. “—” = not published or not covered in our check. Scores are our editorial estimate (0–100) of value per dollar — limits per price weighted against metadata posture and signup availability.
- Proton Plus: $2.49/mo is the current standard first-year promo ($29.88); renewal is $47.88/yr = $3.99/mo — the page shows no $3.99 entry price.
- Mailbox.org storage was doubled on 2026-07-15: new prices for new customers immediately, existing customers from 2026-09-01; Light unchanged at 2GB.
Adding up a stack for your team? Run your own numbers → the free email stack calculator — inbox + alias, per user, promo vs renewal.
Alias services — bandwidth and reply rights, not alias counts
Every service in this table can hand you “unlimited” something. The metric that separates them: monthly bandwidth (Addy.io Free: 10MB/month), whether replies work (Relay Free: no), and whether you can start a new thread from an alias at all (Relay: never; DDG: via a workaround format). Sorted by value per dollar.
The only free alias tier where replies work out of the box — 10 aliases, unlimited forwarding bandwidth (25MB per email), one mailbox.
| Service | Price | Aliases | Bandwidth | Reply | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SimpleLogin Premium Value pick | $36/year or $4 billed monthly | Unlimited | Unlimited (25MB per email cap) | Yes | 92/100 |
| SimpleLogin Free | $0 | 10 | Unlimited (25MB per email cap) | Yes — even on Free | 88/100 |
| Addy.io Pro | $36/year $3/mo | Unlimited standard + unlimited shared-domain | Unlimited | Yes — 200 replies/sends a day | 84/100 |
| Addy.io Lite | $12/year $1/mo | Unlimited standard (shared-domain: —) | 100MB/month | Yes — 50 replies/sends a day | 76/100 |
| DuckDuckGo Email Protection | $0 no paid tier | Unlimited @duck.com (daily abuse limit) | — | Yes — replies route through duck.com | 70/100 |
| Apple Hide My Email | iCloud+ from $0.99/mo 50GB, US | — (no published limit; community reports a soft cap ≈700 — anecdotal) | — | Yes — via Apple Mail / iCloud web | 63/100 |
| Addy.io Free | $0 | Unlimited standard (subdomain) + 10 shared-domain | 10MB / MONTH | No | 55/100 |
| Firefox Relay Premium | Not published — waitlist checked 2026-11-13 | Unlimited masks | 10MB/email forwarding cap | Yes — within 3 months of receiving | — |
| Firefox Relay Free | $0 | 5 masks | 10MB/email forwarding cap | No — “not included” on Free | 48/100 |
Firefox Relay Premium keeps its feature row but carries no score: with no published price there is nothing to rank. Initiate rights and custom-domain support moved to each service's review page (click the name). Scores are our editorial estimate (0–100) of value per dollar — price against bandwidth, reply rights, initiate rights and domain support.
- Addy.io Free: unlimited aliases, 10MB of monthly bandwidth — the alias generator never stops, the pipe does.
- SimpleLogin caps every forwarded email at 25MB (FAQ) — bandwidth is unlimited, per-message size is not.
- Firefox Relay drops anything over 10MB — attachments die at the relay on every tier.
10 recipients = 10 emailshow Proton Free’s 150/day actually counts
The $0 reality — what “free” actually leaves you
Every provider above has a $0 story. This is what remains after the marketing drains out: the one limit that will actually stop your week — a sending cap, a bandwidth meter, or a reply that silently never arrives.
| Service | What $0 actually buys | The catch |
|---|---|---|
| | 1GB Mail (+5GB Drive via checklist), 10 hide-my-email aliases, 150 messages/day (50/hour), zero-access storage | Every recipient counts toward 150; no Bridge/IMAP; @pm.me closed to new free accounts; 3 folders / 3 labels / 1 filter |
| | 1GB, E2E including subject inside Tuta | 1 calendar, 3 labels, and none of: aliases, custom domain, catch-all, import, auto-reply |
| SimpleLogin Free | 10 aliases, unlimited bandwidth (25MB/email), replies work, 1 mailbox | 10 aliases total; initiating a new thread from an alias needs Premium (reverse-alias) |
| Addy.io Free | Unlimited standard aliases + 10 shared-domain, 1 recipient | 10MB/month bandwidth — the alias count is unlimited, the pipe is not; no replies |
| Firefox Relay Free | 5 email masks | No reply on Free (and Premium itself is waitlisted, unpriced); emails over 10MB are not forwarded |
| DuckDuckGo Email Protection | Unlimited @duck.com addresses, tracker removal, replies work | Replies break on domains without SPF; initiating needs the [email protected] workaround format; no dashboard — manage in the browser |
| Apple Hide My Email | Nothing at $0 — iCloud+ required (from $0.99/mo, 50GB US) | Reply via Apple clients only; no initiating; no custom domains; the address cap is undocumented |
The catch column reads as a warning on purpose: on a free tier the catch, not the feature list, is the product. Apple Hide My Email is listed to make the point — it is the alias service with no free tier.
Metadata: what the provider always sees
Encryption buys you the body, not the envelope. Whoever runs your mailbox routes your mail — so they see From, To and timestamps (plus your connecting IP) on every message, encrypted or not. Tuta says it outright: the only fields that stay unencrypted are addresses and dates. And here is the part most “end-to-end encrypted” marketing skips: OpenPGP does not encrypt the subject line — PGP/MIME (RFC 3156) covers the body and attachments only; the Subject header travels as plaintext. Proton is the exception that additionally encrypts the subject at rest (zero-access); Tuta encrypts the subject end-to-end — but only Tuta-to-Tuta, or to an outsider via its password-protected mode. A plain message to Gmail is encrypted nowhere until it reaches Tuta’s own servers.
| Provider | Subject E2E, internal | Subject E2E, password-protected external | Subject E2E, plain external (Gmail) | Subject at rest, their servers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| | Subject E2E encrypted | Subject E2E encrypted | No — plaintext over SMTP | Encrypted (own post-quantum protocol, not PGP) |
| | Body only* | Body only | No — plaintext in transit | Encrypted — zero-access (the exception) |
| Mailbox.org | Body only | Body only | No | Depends on client / incoming auto-encrypt |
| StartMail | Body only | Password-protected variant | No | Encrypted |
| CounterMail | Body only | Body only | No | Encrypted (diskless servers) |
*“Body only” = with OpenPGP providers, E2EE covers body + attachments but never the Subject header (RFC 3156). Proton is unique in additionally encrypting the subject at rest (zero-access). Tuta uses its own post-quantum protocol, not PGP — hence the subject coverage inside its network.
Traps — the fine print that changes the deal
Verified against official pages on 2026-11-13. Anecdotes are labeled as anecdotes; unpublished numbers stay “—”.
- Proton @pm.me: the short receive-only address is closed to new Free accounts — existing users keep it, new ones must pay to activate it at all.
- Addy.io Free’s 10MB/month bandwidth sits under an “unlimited aliases” headline — the marketing column and the meter column are not the same column.
- Firefox Relay publishes no prices: as of 2026-11-13 every pricing cell is empty and the buttons say “Join the Waitlist” — the VPN bundle price is equally invisible.
- DuckDuckGo’s SPF trap: if your forwarding address lives on a unique domain without an SPF record, replies from your @duck.com alias are not supported — they just don’t go.
- Apple Hide My Email’s ~700-address soft cap is anecdotal (Reddit / Apple Communities) — Apple documents no limit, so plan for “undocumented”, not for 700.
- Proton Plus $2.49/mo is first-year only; the renewal is $47.88/yr ($3.99/mo) — the page never shows $3.99 as an entry price.
- StartMail Business monthly billing is not plainly published (~$10.99 in one render; “Save $24” arithmetic implies $8.99) — only the annual $6.99/mo is quotable.
- CounterMail is “closed to new registrations” — plan prices without a checkout are a rumor, not a product.
- The destination mailbox is the weakest link: an alias account without 2FA means a stolen password can silently re-point where your aliases deliver — and a destination inbox without 2FA receives everything they forward.
The open-source path — self-host the alias layer
Both top alias services are open source and self-hostable: SimpleLogin and Addy.io publish their code, and your own instance carries none of the hosted-plan limits — no 10-alias cap, no 10MB/month meter, no 25MB per-email ceiling. The bill becomes a ~$5/mo VPS plus your own diligence: DNS, certificates, backups — and deliverability. A fresh self-hosted IP starts with no reputation, so expect to earn your way into inboxes that hosted services walk into. For most people the hosted tiers above are still the sane start; self-hosting is the ceiling remover when the limits — not the price — become the problem.
Deep dives
- The Real Cost of a Private Inbox — $/GB per year, the sending caps that actually limit you, and the €12/yr minimum PGP stack
- Email Aliases: What We Learned Setting Ours Up — our Proton + SimpleLogin setup, and the bandwidth/reply traps that ruled others out
- Your Encrypted Email Leaks Its Subject Line — what OpenPGP encrypts, what it never does, and the metadata every provider sees
- Gmail + Aliases Is Enough — the threat model where $0 wins, and the €1/mo escape hatch when it stops winning