Your Encrypted Email Leaks Its Subject Line
0 — providers that E2E-encrypt your subject to Gmail the number that matters here
By Stan K.
OpenPGP (PGP/MIME, RFC 3156) encrypts the body and attachments — never the Subject header. Proton encrypts the subject at rest; Tuta encrypts it end-to-end only Tuta-to-Tuta or via password-protected external. To a plain Gmail recipient, no verified provider encrypts your subject at all — and From, To, timestamps and IP stay visible to every provider.
“End-to-end encrypted email” is the most oversold phrase in privacy marketing, because the standard underneath it draws a smaller circle than buyers assume. OpenPGP — the standard behind Proton’s external encryption, Mailbox.org’s Guard, StartMail and CounterMail — encrypts the body and attachments. The Subject header travels as plaintext. Tuta says it outright in its own encryption docs: “unlike PGP (which does not encrypt the subject line).” Subjects like “Question about the biopsy results” or “Wire transfer confirmation” ride every hop in the clear.
What PGP actually encrypts
PGP/MIME (RFC 3156) covers the MIME parts — the body and the attachments. Headers sit outside the envelope by design. The verified matrix, provider by provider:
| Provider | Subject E2E, internal | Subject E2E, password-protected external | Subject to plain external (Gmail) | Subject at rest, their servers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tuta | Encrypted (own protocol) | Encrypted | No — plaintext over SMTP | Encrypted |
| Proton Mail | Body only | Body only | No | Encrypted, zero-access |
| Mailbox.org | Body only | Body only | No | Depends on client |
| StartMail | Body only | Password-protected variant | No | Encrypted |
| CounterMail | Body only | Body only | No | Encrypted (diskless) |
The column that matters is the third one: zero of five providers encrypt your subject end-to-end when the recipient is on plain external mail. If your correspondent reads in Gmail or Outlook — which is nearly every correspondent — the subject line is metadata in the open, whatever the homepage promises.
The two partial exceptions
Proton is the exception at rest: the subject gets zero-access encryption on Proton’s own servers — unique among PGP providers. But that protects the mailbox, not the wire; in transit to an external recipient, the subject is plaintext.
Tuta is the exception in transit — with edges. Tuta-to-Tuta, the subject is end-to-end encrypted (their own post-quantum protocol, not PGP). To an outsider via password-protected mode, still encrypted. To a plain Gmail address: nothing — the message is encrypted only once it reaches Tuta’s servers. Internal-only encryption is real encryption, but your correspondents decide which column you land in, not you.
The metadata that never hides — and the weakest link
Whoever runs your mailbox routes your mail, so they see From, To, timestamps — and your connecting IP on every message, encrypted or not. Tuta is the one provider that says it plainly: the unencrypted fields are the addresses and the dates. Encryption buys the body; the envelope remains a business record.
Two more verified edges worth knowing. Proton’s short @pm.me address is closed to new free accounts — existing users keep it, new ones must pay to activate it at all. And the weakest link is rarely the cipher: an alias account without 2FA means a stolen password can silently re-point where your aliases deliver — and a destination inbox without 2FA receives everything they forward. Which tier buys which posture, priced per year, is in The Real Cost of a Private Inbox; the full subject matrix with source links lives in the Email privacy hub.