Video generation: ranked by the cost of one usable 5-second clip
The easy pick by value, not by hype. Our metric is what a usable 5-second clip costs — generated is not usable: motion artifacts, broken physics and dead audio get clips rejected, and every reject burns the same credits, so assume ×2–4 on the sticker for real work. Every $/clip below comes from official pricing pages (credit conversions marked); where the vendor hides the price the cell stays “—” until it can be verified. The Artificial Analysis Video Elo appears only as a quality reference.
Open-source & local — you pay electricity
No per-unit price exists here: the cost model is watts. A 170 W card draws ≈$0.03/hour at the US average rate ($0.18/kWh — the same default as our rent-vs-own calculator), and a rejected clip costs a re-roll, not a credit. Our own 3060 box runs a closed video pipeline (agent writes, Kokoro voices, ComfyUI renders) — but no verified 3060 video-model report exists yet, so no row below claims one. Sorted by value per VRAM — license traps cap the score.
| Model | License | VRAM / needs | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wan 2.2 TI2V-5B 5B params Value pick | Apache 2.0 | 24 GB (official) · <9 min/720p clip | 88/100 |
| LTX-2.5 19B params Only local audio+video | Apache (code) · Community weights | — · fp8/fp4 quants | 76/100 |
| HunyuanVideo 1.5 8.3B params | Tencent Community · NC in EU/UK/KR | 14 GB min (offload) | 58/100 |
| Mochi 1 | Apache 2.0 | ~60 GB · <20 GB in ComfyUI | 52/100 |
| Wan 2.2 T2V/I2V-A14B 14B params | Apache 2.0 | 80 GB (official) | 48/100 |
| | MIT | — | 44/100 |
| Kandinsky 6.0 Pro | MIT · gated | — | 40/100 |
| Open-Sora | Apache 2.0 | — | 36/100 |
| MiniMax-H3 33B params | Community · US-banned | — | 6/100 |
Click a model for the full picture — license terms, hardware paths and the score breakdown on its review page. “—” in VRAM = verify pending: we publish hardware requirements only when a source confirms them. Scores are our editorial estimate (0–100) of value per VRAM. The 12 GB GGUF path is community territory — no verified 3060 report exists; everything else cites LICENSE files and model cards.
- MiniMax-H3: the LICENSE (2026-08-02) excludes the USA, EU, UK and Korea — for US work it is unusable, full stop.
- HunyuanVideo 1.5: the community license excludes the EU, UK and South Korea — the USA is explicitly OK (the opposite of the early rumors; read before betting).
- LTX-2.5: the community weights are revenue-capped — free while you stay under $10M/yr (license corrected 2026-10-29).
- Kandinsky 6.0 Pro: the weights are gated — “open” here means ask first.
- Wan 2.2 T2V/I2V-A14B: 80 GB official is not a consumer card; the GGUF path to a 3060 is theoretical (no confirmed user report).
Paid APIs — ranked by value per dollar
Same unit for everyone: the official price of one 5-second clip where the vendor publishes per-second or per-clip rates; credit-billed rows are converted at the entry tier and marked. Sorted by value per dollar — the quality king is not automatically the value king.
| Provider | Entry tier | $/5s clip | Commercial from | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| | $12/1M video tokens PAYG API — no subscription | ≈$0.35/5s 720p (audio incl.) | API — no separate license tier | 90/100 |
| FLUX 3 Video (BFL) | PAYG — no subscription billed per second | HD $0.75/5s · Draft HD $0.30/5s | API | 86/100 |
| Pika (aggregator) | Starter $10/mo 600 credits · Free → Fancy $95+ | H3 Flex ≈$0.17/5s (10 cr.) | Starter ($10/mo) — Free has none | 74/100 |
| Runway | Standard $12/mo Free 125 cr. → Max $76 (9,500 cr.) | Gen-4.5 60 cr./5s · Seedance 2.5 720p 30 cr./s | Every plan (incl. Free) | 70/100 |
| Seedance 2.5 direct (BytePlus) | PAYG — $32 / 5M tokens | ≈$0.32–1.35/5s (480p) | API | 62/100 |
| Luma | Plus $30/mo 10k cr. → Ultra $300 (150k cr.) | — | — | — |
| Kling | Plans from $6.99 | — | — | — |
| Hailuo | No readable price — JS-only page | — | — | — |
| Midjourney (video) | Standard+ plans Relax mode | — | Standard+ · >$1M → Pro/Mega | — |
Sora (OpenAI) — discontinued, kept off the board on purpose. Web/app shut 2026-04-26, API 2026-09-24, stored data to be “permanently deleted”. A row you cannot buy is not an option — it is the lesson: rented video infrastructure can vanish between invoices, twice in one year (Sora, then Veo 3.1 Preview on 2026-10-22).
Click a provider for the full picture — traps, credit math and the score breakdown on its review page. Rows with “—” scores are not ranked and carry no review page yet: no public per-clip pricing means nothing to verify. Scores are our editorial estimate (0–100) of value per dollar — quality (AA Elo) is one input, price per usable clip is the other.
- Pika: the free plan carries NO commercial license — the only plan-gated license on this page; rights start at Starter ($10/mo).
- Google stamps SynthID on every Omni video — official, no opt-out.
- Wrapper premium: Seedance 2.5 via Pika runs ≈$2.03/5s at 720p (122 cr.) against ≈$0.32–1.35 direct at 480p — compare before committing.
- Credits that burn: Pika plan credits don’t roll over (top-ups $1 = 60 cr. last 365 days); Luma credits expire at the end of the billing cycle and subscriptions pause at the spending limit; Runway rollover exists only on Max (1 month) — purchased credits never expire.
- Unranked rows: Kling’s per-model credits (1.6 vs 2.x) sit behind JS/login; Hailuo’s pricing page is JS-only; Midjourney video rides the Relax queue on Standard+ (720p needs Standard/Pro/Mega) with per-clip economics not published.
×2–4 rejectsthe multiplier on every price above
Pipeline economics — local electricity vs API vs premium subscriptions for a full script→voice→video loop — get their own article: Our Video Pipeline Runs Local; this hub sticks strictly to per-clip prices.
Quality reference — AA Video Leaderboard Elo
Blind-vote preference Elo from Artificial Analysis — read it next to the price, never instead of it. The curiosity worth pausing on: the Elo king is Wan 3.0 at 1175 — the same family whose Wan 2.2 release runs locally under Apache 2.0 (table 1); FLUX 3 follows at 1137.
| Model | Elo | AA-listed price |
|---|---|---|
| Wan 3.0 | 1175 | — |
| FLUX 3 | 1137 | — |
Snapshot 2026-11-12. Only these two rows were extracted from the board — no more rows are invented. AA-listed prices across the video leaderboard run $2.40–34.12/min; per-model attribution wasn’t captured (verify pending). Paid-table prices come from official pricing pages (Google AI, bfl.ai, Runway, Pika); Elo from the AA Video Leaderboard. Licenses from LICENSE files and model cards.
The stack around video generation
Local video gen is the top layer of a stack you can own: One GPU Beats Ten Subscriptions shows the closed pipeline our 3060 box actually runs (agent writes, Kokoro voices, ComfyUI renders — zero per-call bills for the media layer), and the Local GPU AI leaderboard ranks the hardware it runs on. The voice layer lives in the TTS hub, stills and thumbnails in the Image generation hub; for the thinking layer, see the AI Coding Plans ranking. The dedicated video deep dives — per-keeper math, our local pipeline, the fine-print traps — are in the Deep dives section below.
What to look for in a video generator
A clip you keep is the unit
Every vendor quotes the happy path per generated clip. Divide by your real keeper rate before comparing — ×2–4 is normal in video — and a local model that re-rolls for electricity changes the economics entirely.
Endpoints have expiration dates
Sora vanished in two steps (web 2026-04-26, API 2026-09-24) and took users’ data with it; Google sunset Veo 3.1 Preview a month later. Never route client work through a single rented endpoint without a fallback — the local table is that fallback.
Credits that burn monthly
Luma credits expire every billing cycle; Pika’s plan credits don’t roll over; Runway grants rollover only on Max (1 month) — while purchased credits survive (Pika 365 days, Runway unlimited). A subscription punishes every idle month.
License territories and free-tier rights
MiniMax-H3 bans the USA outright; HunyuanVideo 1.5 bans the EU/UK/Korea but not the USA; Pika’s free tier has no commercial license while Runway grants commercial rights on every plan. And Google stamps SynthID on every Omni video — a term, not a footnote.
Deep dives
- The Real Cost of a Usable 5-Second Clip — sticker price × keeper rate = the real bill
- Our Video Pipeline Runs Local — Here's Why — composition and iteration at electricity prices
- Video Gen Fine-Print Traps — eight verified traps, from dead products to per-second quotes
- You Probably Don't Need a Video Gen API — the compose-first alternative and clean local licenses