Domains: ranked by the year-2 bill, not the year-1 teaser
A domain is the only hosting line-item where the renewal price is knowable before you buy — and most checkout screens bury it. Our metric is what the name costs in year 1 vs year 2+: the renewal column, the privacy upsell, the transfer math and the redemption window behind it. Every number below comes from official pages checked on 2026-11-13; where a vendor publishes only through JavaScript or blocks verification entirely, the cell stays “—” — GoDaddy’s whole price block is exactly that.
.com registrars — the same name, five different year-2 bills
The verified renewal spread for an identical .com runs $11.81 → $19.98 — pure registrar markup on top of the same registry product. Privacy is free for life at four of the five; the difference is what happens at renewal, and whether your DNS is hostage. Sorted by value.
Flat $11.81 — registration = renewal = transfer, straight from the official pricing API — plus WHOIS privacy free for life and no nameserver lock. The one registrar whose year-2 bill equals the year-1 bill.
| Registrar | Price .com (yr 1 → renewal) | WHOIS privacy | Nameservers / DNS | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| | $11.81/yr coupon −$1 first year → $10.81 · renewal $11.81 — flat: registration = renewal = transfer | Free for life | No lock — any DNS host | 93/100 |
| | At-cost registry wholesale + ICANN fee, no markup — exact figure “—” (JS challenge) · renewal = registration, moves only when the wholesale moves | Free (WHOIS redaction) | Locked to Cloudflare DNS (explicit) | 86/100 |
| | $12.08 sale 25% off the $15.98 registration price · renewal $19.98/yr — year 2 costs +65% | Free for life | — | 74/100 |
| | — pricing is JS-only, help center publishes no number · .com renewal increase confirmed in progress — amount “—” | Free (Whois Privacy + SSL) | Custom NS break Google-era forwarding | 56/100 |
| | — the site returns 403 to our probes · renewal “—” | Basic free + paid “Full Protection” tier (price “—”) | — | 38/100 |
Click a registrar for the full picture — the fine print now lives on its review page: transfer and grace mechanics, TLD-specific pricing (.io/.ai), paid-protection tiers and the 10-pillar score breakdown. “—” = not verifiable from official pages (GoDaddy returns 403 to probes; Squarespace publishes prices only through JavaScript; Cloudflare’s price API sits behind a challenge). Scores are our editorial estimate (0–100) of value per dollar — flat renewal pricing weighted against privacy cost, nameserver freedom and price transparency. An at-cost price is a promise, not a number: it follows the registry wholesale.
- GoDaddy: “Redemption fees may be applied 12 days after expiration” — the shortest verified grace in this table; miss two weeks and you are in redemption territory.
- Cloudflare’s nameserver lock is explicit: “You will not be able to change to another DNS provider’s nameservers while using Cloudflare Registrar”.
- Namecheap year 2 costs +65% over the year-1 sale ($19.98 vs $12.08) — the teaser is real, so is the step-up.
- Squarespace’s renewal increase is confirmed as fact — “Squarespace is increasing renewals for .xyz, .com, .net, and .org domains” — but the date and amount are not official, so the cells stay “—”.
TLD traps — the rules no registrar can discount
Pick the wrong ending and the year-2 metric stops being a choice: .io renews at 4–6× a .com, .ai bills two years minimum, and .dev/.app never load over plain HTTP — permanently, by design. Registration and renewal figures below are the verified ones only.
| TLD | Registration | Renewal | Minimum term | Traps & fine print |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| .com The default | $11.81 (Porkbun) · $12.08 sale (Namecheap) | $11.81 (Porkbun) · $19.98 (Namecheap) | 1 year |
|
| .io Tech classic, governance question | $51.80 (Porkbun; $28.12 first-year promo) | $50–75+/yr — $51.80 (Porkbun) · $73.49 (101domain) | 1 year |
|
| .ai Anguilla ccTLD, AI gold rush | $82.70/yr × 2 = $165.40 (Porkbun) · $49.99 promo + $150 ≈ $200 (101domain) | $82.70/yr (Porkbun) · $143/yr (101domain) | 2 years — mandatory |
|
| .dev / .app Google Registry, HTTPS-only | — (no verified figures) | — | 1 year |
|
.io figures from Porkbun and 101domain; .ai from Porkbun and 101domain (“2-year purchase required”, periods 2–10 years); .dev/.app rules quoted from registry.google — no verified price figures for them, so their cells stay “—”. The .io entry is a long-term governance note, not a retirement warning: the TLD is Active in IANA as of our check.
The quiet mechanics — transfers, locks and the expiry ladder
These rules decide whether a “cheap” domain stays cheap. The good news is structural: a transfer adds its year onto expiry, so switching to a flat-price registrar costs one normal year and loses nothing. The bad news is also structural: a 45-day window after renewal where that math breaks, and a redemption ladder whose fees no registrar publishes in dollars.
| Fee / mechanic | The verified rule | Fine print |
|---|---|---|
| WHOIS privacy | Free at Cloudflare (redaction), Porkbun and Namecheap (“FREE for life”), Squarespace (“Your domain includes free Whois Privacy and SSL”) |
|
| Transfer = +1 year | A transfer adds a year to expiry: “All transfers of gTLD domain names include a one year renewal” (Porkbun); “a transfer adds one year to your current expiration date” (Cloudflare) |
|
| The 45-day rule | Transfer within ~45 days after a renewal and the registry does not add the bonus year — you pay the transfer year and never receive it (Cloudflare FAQ) |
|
| 60-day transfer lock | No transfers for 60 days after registration, after a previous transfer, or after a registrant-contact change (name/org/email) |
|
| EPP / auth-code process | Unlock at the old registrar → get the EPP/auth code → submit it at the new one → approve via the registrant email |
|
| Renewal grace (expired, not gone) | Renew at the standard price, no penalty — Cloudflare: 40 days for most TLDs, and the name still resolves for the first 30 |
|
| Redemption (the expensive part) | After grace the registry holds the name: getting it back = a redemption fee + a renewal at full price. Cloudflare structure: days 41–70 redemption → 5 days pending delete → released |
|
Redemption fees are quoted only as “varies by the registry” (Porkbun) and “varies depending on the TLD” (Cloudflare) — any flat dollar figure circulating for them is unverified, so we publish the mechanics (fee + renewal at full price) instead of invented numbers. ccTLDs can run shorter grace windows and higher restore costs than the gTLD ladder above.
$59 vs $92the same .com, five years, verified list prices
What to look for in a domain bill
The renewal column is the price
$12.08 becomes $19.98 at Namecheap; $11.81 stays $11.81 at Porkbun. Year 1 is a marketing decision — year 2 is the product. Shop the second column and the fifth year takes care of itself.
At-cost follows the wholesale
Cloudflare’s price moves only when the registry’s does — that’s the promise and the exposure. Wholesale-rise rumors without an official page stay rumors; the hedge is a registrar with flat, published pricing.
Time the transfer
The +1-year rule makes switching nearly free; the 45-day rule after a renewal makes it double-billed; the 60-day lock after registration or a contact change makes it impossible. Put all three on the calendar before you move anything.
The TLD sets rules the registrar can’t discount
No promo fixes .ai’s mandatory second year, .io’s renewal corridor, or .dev/.app’s permanent HTTPS requirement. Choose the ending for its rules, then shop the price.