ToolScore

VPN: the multi-year price is the real price

The easy pick by value, not by hype. Our metric is the 3-year total price + jurisdiction + audits — not the intro price on the landing page, and not speed. You won’t find a single speed number on this page: we don’t publish speed claims we can’t measure; the money is in the fine print instead. Every number below comes from official pages checked on 2026-11-13; where a vendor doesn’t publish (Surfshark’s renewal price), the cell stays “—”.

Intro vs year 3 — what 36 months actually cost

The intro price is bait; the renewal is the bill. The 3-year column is the full 36-month cost: intro term plus renewals (24-mo intro + 12 renewal months; 27-mo intro + 9; Mullvad = 36 × €5). The jump is monthly-price basis. Sorted by provider, because the story — not the ranking — is the point.

Value pick Mullvad €5/mo flat · 0% renewal jump

One flat price on a 1-month or a 3-year term — a 0% renewal jump in a market where the confirmed jumps run +134% to +358%.

Provider / plan Intro price/mo Renewal price/mo 3-year total Renewal jump Score
Mullvad The flat-price benchmark €5/mo flat 1 month or 3 years, same price (VAT included) €5/mo €60/yr — unchanged €180 0% 76/100
Proton VPN Plus The +134% classic $2.99/mo $35.88 for the first 12 months; $71.76 for 24 $6.99/mo $83.88/yr $155.64 +134% 66/100
Proton Unlimited Bundle tier (Mail + Drive + VPN) $6.49/mo $77.88/yr; ~$155.76 for 24 months $9.99/mo $119.88/yr ~$275.64 +54% 64/100
NordVPN Basic The +287% renewal $2.99/mo $80.73 for the first 27 months $11.59/mo $139.08/yr $185.04 +287% 55/100
NordVPN Complete The +358% renewal $3.99/mo $107.73 for 27 months $18.29/mo $219.48/yr $272.34 +358% 50/100
NordVPN Prime The expensive “good” plan $6.99/mo $188.73 for 27 months $24.69/mo $296.28/yr $410.94 +324% 46/100
PIA No trap today — checked $2.26/mo $81.20 total for 36 months, “83% off” the $11.95 monthly rate $81.20 every 3 years the same rate (~$2.26/mo) $81.20 0% — renews at the intro rate 62/100
Surfshark Starter Renewal not published $2.49/mo $67.23 for the first 27 months — (“the applicable renewal price” is all the page says — (not computable without the renewal — 54/100

Click a provider for the full picture — the 10-pillar score breakdown, jurisdiction and audit details, protocol and device facts on its review page. Mullvad bills in EUR (VAT included); the rest in USD. Intro rates move daily — NordVPN Basic’s intro has been seen at $2.99–3.49 — the renewal number is the stable one; anchor on it. Proton Unlimited’s intro runs on 12-month cycles (2 × $77.88 = ~$155.76). PIA’s “$2.26/mo” is the real arithmetic ($81.20 ÷ 36), not the marketing “83% off” sticker. Scores are our editorial estimate (0–100) of value — 3-year total price and renewal jump weighted against jurisdiction and audits; the lead-tier row carries the product page’s ToolScore.

Planning a multi-year commit? Run your own numbers → the free VPN 3-year price calculator — intro + renewal = the real 36-month total.

Jurisdiction & audits — who you trust, and who checked them

A no-logs promise is worth exactly as much as the audit behind it. Sweden in the 14-eyes sounds bad until you read the raid report; a Deloitte badge sounds good until you check whose scope it actually covers. Our rule: official URL or “—” — widely-reported audits that the vendor’s own audit page doesn’t show don’t count here.

Provider Registered in Audits (no-logs, official)
Mullvad Sweden — 14-eyes territory, but no data-retention law applies to VPNs (the Swedish LAD targets telecom operators only). The 2023-04-18 police raid in Gothenburg ended with zero customer data taken. 10+ audits by 6 independent firms incl. Cure53 and Assured — newest 2026 (the audit page lists 10 publications)
Proton VPN Switzerland (Proton AG, Geneva) — outside the 14-eyes Securitum, annually — 5th consecutive report (2026)
NordVPN Panama (incorporated there; Nord Security group with Lithuanian and Dutch offices) PwC (Switzerland) 2018 + 2020 — confirmed on the official audit blog. Deloitte 2022–2025: widely reported, but the official page stops at 2020 → “—” until an official URL shows up
Surfshark Netherlands — 9-eyes; merged with Nord Security (2022) Deloitte no-logs — Jan 2023, re-verified June 2025
PIA USA — 5-eyes; owned by Kape Technologies (British-Israeli, $95M acquisition, 2019) Deloitte 2022 (cross-checked). A claimed Deloitte 2024 — not verified → “—”. The two federal court cases (2016–2017) where no logs were produced are widely reported, but not verifiable from an official URL

Click a provider for the full picture — protocol and device facts, the RAM-only claims and the audit caveats live on its review page. Jurisdiction facts cross-checked against Wikipedia where official pages are SPA/quiet (Mullvad, NordVPN, PIA/Kape). The 14/9/5-eyes labels describe surveillance alliances, not a smoking gun — they matter only together with retention law and audit history.

Free tiers — the two that are actually free

Most “free VPNs” are data harvests with an app icon. Two aren’t: Proton’s free tier (the only confirmed unlimited-data free VPN, no speed cap, no ads) and Windscribe’s 10 GB with unlimited devices. Where the official pages stay quiet (Windscribe’s free-tier P2P, exact country lists), we stay at “—”.

Free plan Data / month Devices Servers P2P / limits
Proton VPN Free Unlimited — “no data or time limits, free forever”, no speed cap, no ads 1 device No server choice — auto-assigned from a few countries (US, NL and Japan among them; the exact count isn’t published today) P2P, streaming and the ad-blocker are paid features — the free tier is a privacy tunnel, not a unlocker
Windscribe Free 10 GB/month with email confirmation (“email to get 10GB of data every month”) Unlimited (“unlimited personal devices”) Manual server pick — the country list/count isn’t published on the pages we checked (historic: ~10 locations) P2P on the free tier: not stated explicitly on the official pages — we leave it “—” rather than guess

Quotes from protonvpn.com/free-vpn and windscribe.com/upgrade/free, checked 2026-11-13. Free tiers are for privacy and light use — the paid features (server choice, P2P, streaming) are exactly what the intro-vs-year-3 game above is selling.

+287–358%the confirmed NordVPN renewal jump (monthly basis)

NordVPN Basic renews at $11.59/mo after a $2.99 intro (+287%), Complete at $18.29 (+358%), Prime at $296.28/yr (+324%). Proton VPN Plus: +134%, Unlimited +54%. The zeros: Mullvad by design (one flat €5), PIA as of today (renews at the same $81.20/3yr). Surfshark: unpriced — no number, no jump, no total.
When free wins — and when it doesn’t
Free wins for light privacy use: Proton VPN Free is unlimited data with no speed cap — but 1 device, no server choice and no P2P. Windscribe spreads 10 GB over unlimited devices. Paid wins the moment you need to pick a country, torrent, or stream — and that’s precisely the moment the renewal math in table 1 starts mattering: buy on the intro, cancel before it renews.

Traps — and one trap that died

The jump only bites on auto-renew

The renewal price applies when the intro term auto-renews. The standard move is to cancel before the term ends and buy a new promo — same vendor or competitor, intro prices exist to be churned. Auto-renewing a 27-month NordVPN intro costs $139.08–296.28/yr; nobody who re-buys pays that.

An unpublished renewal is a red flag

Surfshark confirms the $2.49/mo intro on its pricing page, but the renewal is only ever “the applicable renewal price”. An unpriced renewal can be anything — so the cell stays “—”, the 3-year total is not computable, and that silence is itself the data point.

Prime hides as the “good” plan

NordVPN’s Prime tier looks like the premium, safe choice ($6.99/mo intro) and quietly carries the heaviest bill on the board: $410.94 over 3 years, $296.28/yr at renewal — more than double Basic’s 3-year total, for the same core VPN plus bundle features.

PIA: the trap story is stale — we checked

The “PIA +224% renewal jump” story is dead as of 2026-11-13: the current 3-year plan costs $81.20 total and autorenews at the same $81.20/3yr (~$2.26/mo). The past jumps were real; today’s page is clean. We report both, honestly.

Renting a real US phone — the anti-emulator market

A whole niche rents dedicated physical phones hosted in the US — real device, real carrier SIM, browser remote control from anywhere. What you buy is three things a proxy can never give: a hardware fingerprint (real IMEI, sensors, Play Store), a real US phone number that passes SMS verification, and a carrier mobile IP. Prices verified on each provider's own page on 2026-11-13.

Service Price/mo Device & SIM Data Notes
Roamrig$99 ($109 first)Android + US numberUnlimited high-speedNo minimum, browser streaming
CellGods$80–100Android / iPhone + own SIMUnlimitedFlorida, 100+ phones; $10/day
QuantumPhones$100–120Android / iPhone, fleet dashboardUnlimited−40% on 12-mo plan
HiveReach$99.99 ($79.99 annual)Android + carrier SIM—7 countries incl. US
DistrictDroid$150Pixel + physical T-Mobile SIM—Texas; $30/day, no contract
Muxtream$130Android + US SIM, live video+audio—$50/week
RentPhoneUSA$130 ($60 no SIM)Android, AT&T/T-Mobile/Verizon choice—No contract
Hardline Phone$80 (+$120 camera)Android + US numberIncludedCamera defeats black-screen detection; crypto, no-KYC
DroidDeskfrom $180Marketplace, host-operatedVaries$5/hour, many countries
CloudPhoneHub$29–89Shared / dedicated / pro Android—Crypto, no-KYC; location unclear

“Unlimited” is claimed on the pricing page only by Roamrig, CellGods and QuantumPhones — others leave the cap unspecified (marked “—”). SignalGalaxy, Phonect and RemoteWave advertise the same service but publish no prices (JS-only pages) — not listed. Proxidize no longer sells its modem kits; it is now a managed mobile-proxy service ($59/proxy/mo or $2/GB, KYC required).

3–4× vs owningRental vs owned line vs proxy

A rented dedicated phone at $99–130/mo costs roughly 3–4× an owned US line (Visible+ $35/mo + your own handset) — but it needs no US address, no KYC (at several providers), swaps the device on ban, and runs 24/7 in someone else’s facility. Versus mobile proxies (IPRoyal $5.60/GB; Proxidize $2/GB or $59/proxy) it is expensive per GB yet the only option that also sells the hardware fingerprint and a real SIM number — emulators and proxies fail where a physical device passes.

Who this market serves

Social-media agencies and account operators outside the US (TikTok/Instagram/OFM), app-store verification, anything where emulator detection kills accounts. DistrictDroid advertises under 5% ban rates versus 60–80% on emulators — vendor claim, not our measurement. Control is a private browser link with screen streaming (tap/type/clipboard); Muxtream adds live audio, Hardline a physical camera pointed at the screen.

The open-source bridge

Own the stack instead of renting it: a US line (Visible+ $35) in your own phone or a 4G modem on OpenWrt (qmi/mbim, ~$50–150 hardware), Termux squid for a proxy, WireGuard to your VPS. The software is 100% free — the real costs are the line, the handset and the fact that you, not a vendor, handle bans.

The open-source path — WireGuard on a $5 VPS

You can skip the subscription game entirely: self-hosted WireGuard on a $5/month VPS is your own endpoint, and the flat VPS price is the whole cost — no per-GB billing, no renewal games, no intro term. It’s the same protocol Mullvad standardized on (WireGuard-only since 2026-01-15). What it is not: anonymity. You’ve moved trust from a VPN vendor to a VPS vendor — the tunnel is encrypted and the endpoint is yours, but the IP is a datacenter IP tied to a payment account, with no shared crowd and no no-logs audit standing behind it. A self-hosted tunnel is crypto, not a new identity.

The IP world next door

VPNs are the privacy side of the IP market; the Data & Scraping hub is the buyer side — what IPs cost by the gigabyte when you’re the customer, and the same fine-print discipline (expiry traps, unpublishable prices) applied to proxy pools. The Cloud Storage hub runs the identical renewal-jump math on storage subscriptions.

Deep dives

Data freshness & sources
Snapshot 2026-11-13, US pricing (Mullvad in EUR, VAT included). Every number was checked against official pages on that date — pricing (mullvad.net, protonvpn.com, nordvpn.com, privateinternetaccess.com, surfshark.com, windscribe.com, protonvpn.com/free); audits and infrastructure (Mullvad audits, Mullvad OpenVPN removal, Proton × Securitum, NordVPN × PwC, Surfshark × Deloitte), with Wikipedia cross-checks where official pages are SPAs. VPN intro rates move daily and renewal prices move annually — cells without a source stay “—” until verified. No speed numbers appear on this page: we don’t publish speed claims we can’t measure.