ToolScore

Your Browser's Password Manager Is Probably Enough

$0 covers the security part the number that matters here

By Stan K.

For most threat models, $0 covers the security part completely: Bitwarden Free gives unlimited passwords, passkeys and devices with the same encryption as the paid tier; Dashlane Free exists (25 passwords); 1Password has no free tier at all. Paid password managers are for households and teams — the honest test for which one you are.

The password-manager market sells like insurance: pay, or remain vulnerable. Start with the threat model instead. For most people the adversary is password reuse and phishing — not a targeted attacker who defeated the browser’s local encryption. Against that adversary, the manager built into your browser, or a free dedicated vault, covers the security part completely. What money buys is convenience and sharing, and pretending otherwise is how a $47.88/year subscription ends up on the card of a person with one laptop.

What $0 already includes — verified, not vibes

We checked every free tier against the live plan pages on 2026-11-13:

  • Bitwarden Free is the most generous: unlimited passwords, passkeys and devices, sharing with one other user, Bitwarden Send, encrypted export. The encryption is identical to the paid tier — free here is a complete product, not a demo.
  • Proton Pass Free gives unlimited logins, notes and devices plus 10 hide-my-email aliases — and, contrary to the rumor mill, it does include 2 vaults and 1 GB of storage.
  • Dashlane Free exists. The “killed in October 2025” story is false; Dashlane actively advertises it — but the 25-password cap makes it a trial in disguise, fine for one browser, not for a life.
  • Keeper is a freemium shell limited to one device.
  • 1Password has no free tier at all — a 14-day trial, no credit card required, then you pay.

Add the direction browsers are already going — passkey support in the managers people actually have installed — and the $0 stack is stronger than the marketing admits.

What money actually buys

None of which means paid tiers are scams. It means they sell specific things, and you should be able to name them before paying:

  • TOTP in the same vault. Bitwarden Premium ($19.80/yr) puts your one-time codes next to your passwords; Proton’s free tier omits the built-in authenticator entirely.
  • A household’s shared logins. This is the big one. The moment a second person needs the utility and streaming accounts, a family plan beats sending passwords over chat — and the per-person floor is $7.98/year (Bitwarden Families, $47.88 split across 6 seats, flat at renewal).
  • Emergency access. Bitwarden Premium includes it — the mechanism for someone to inherit your vault without sharing the master password now.
  • Attachments and reports. 5 GB of file storage and vault health reports on Bitwarden Premium; dark-web monitoring on Proton’s paid tier.
The honest test

Can you name the feature you’re paying for? If the answer is “better security,” you’re paying for marketing — free and paid tiers ship the same encryption. If the answer is “my partner needs the logins” or “I want TOTP in one place,” you have a real requirement and the family math will find your price.

The conclusion: paid is for households and teams

A solo user with the browser’s manager, or Bitwarden Free, plus passkeys where offered, is not being irresponsible — they are matching spend to threat model. The paid product genuinely starts at the second person: families divide to $7.98–$14.38 per head (the full per-person math), and teams have their own ladder — 1Password Business runs $8.99/user/mo billed yearly. If you live alone and can’t name a feature from the list above, keep the $0. Everyone else: the verified family and individual tables, free-tier reality checks and breach history are in the Password Managers hub.

Numbers change — the math doesn't
Token prices and plan limits shift monthly; the structural arguments in this guide age slowly. For current per-tool numbers see the live rankings.